Renzo Piano’s the Shard and Central St. Giles: Built for the 1 Percent, Open to the Rest

Renzo Piano’s sky-scraping London Bridge Tower, known better as the Shard, brings new life to the London skyline, but remains inaccessible to the masses. It eclipses his nearby central St. Giles, which more successfully balances big-ticket design with the needs of the common folk.

8 MIN READ
Renzo Piano’s Shard clocks in at 72 stories—by far the tallest building on the city’s skyline. The price tag for development and construction was $2.4 billion, and that high cost translates to a look-but-don’t-touch approach for all but the upper echelons of London society.

Arcaid Images

Renzo Piano’s Shard clocks in at 72 stories—by far the tallest building on the city’s skyline. The price tag for development and construction was $2.4 billion, and that high cost translates to a look-but-don’t-touch approach for all but the upper echelons of London society.

Central St. Giles solicits a completely different feeling, one that is much more engrained in the life of London. Nestled between the Soho theater district and Bloomsbury, the project’s several-hundred glazed, ceramic panels present a perforated skin that speaks to the street with the bright orange, lime green, and canary yellow colors of theater marquees. Here, as at the Shard, the designers have hung the façades as free planes with staggered placements, leaving lots of reveals that eliminate any sense of monolithic massing. At ground level, six small blocks surround an open court that can be accessed from different directions by five different paths, and Mediterranean-style cafés and restaurants occupy most of the grade-level spaces. On the upper stories, the volumes divide into a 15-story, two-part housing block on the west and a 12-story, U-shaped office block on the east.

The size of the office floor plates, of over 4,000 square meters (43,055 square feet), are unique to central London and have attracted several important media companies, including NBCUniversal, Google, and Mindshare. They have primarily organized their workspaces like lofts to encourage the collaborative methods of people in media, most of whom seem progressive and appear to be under 40. The top three floors of this block boast roof gardens and special outdoor work areas, while all levels have corner “winter gardens”—special glazed terraces for private meetings. Urged by the London Council, the developers reduced the amount of automobile parking in the basement to 40 spaces, while providing showers and safe parking for hundreds of bikers. The basement also contains London’s first biomass boiler, which provides central heating for the entire complex. Harvested rainwater is also used in the bathrooms and watering systems.

Housing presented the thorniest part of the planning of Central St. Giles. As with the Shard, the developers were obliged to provide a certain percentage of affordable units, but instead of relocating the lower-income residences to some other part of town, they kept them on-site. Half of the 109 units are social housing, rented for a minimum fee, while the other half are rather expensive apartments, selling for as much as £5 million ($8.1 million). The good intentions go only so far, though, in that the expensive units’ entries face the nice inner court while the poor ones enter from a dingy back street. Meanwhile, the elevations of the “piazza” were toned down to gray ceramic panels, leaving the bright colors for the sculptures and chairs, some of which belong to the restaurants while others are for those hanging out. (The space is always open to the public and has 24-hour security.)

Piano, in his quest to recreate the sense of freedom of association found in the Italian piazza, has given London a unique social space of great vitality. Such a program, with its youthful, loft-like offices; open-air restaurants; mixed-income housing; and, above all, public piazza that allows for the sort of biographical diversity that traditional cities have always provided, sends a clear message that no matter how much they may own, the city does not belong exclusively to the 1 percent.

Piano, in his quest to recreate [at central st. giles] the sense of freedom of association found in the italian piazza, has given London a unique social space of great vitality.

About the Author

Richard Ingersoll

Richard Ingersoll was born near San Francisco in 1949 but has spent half of his life in Italy. He earned a Ph.D. in architectural history at the University of California, Berkeley, in 1985. From 1983 to 1998 he was the editor-in-chief of Design Book Review, and from 1986 to 1997 he taught at Rice University in Houston. He lives full-time in Tuscany, teaching at Syracuse University in Florence, and he has also taught at Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule, in Zürich; Facoltà di Architettura di Ferrara, in Ferrari, Italy; Universidad de Navarra, in Pamplona, Spain; and Peking University, in Beijing. Ingersoll was a frequent contributor for Architecture, the precursor of ARCHITECT, and he currently writes for Arquitectura Viva, Lotus, Il Giornale di Architettura, Bauwelt, World Architecture (Beijing), and C3 (Seoul).

No recommended contents to display.

Upcoming Events

  • Design Smarter: Leveraging GIS, BIM, and Open Data for Better Site Selection & Collaboration

    Live Webinar

    Register for Free
  • Slate Reimagined: The Surprising Advantages of Slate Rainscreen Cladding

    Webinar

    Register Now
  • The State of Residential Design Today: Innovations and Insights from RADA-Winning Architects

    Webinar

    Register for Free
All Events