2015 AL Design Awards: California Palace of the Legion of Honor, Salon Doré, San Francisco

Commendable Achievement—Exhibition Lighting and Temporary Installations

2 MIN READ

Randy Dodson


The Salon Doré
from the Hôtel de La Trémoille in Paris is one of the finest examples of French Neoclassical interior architecture currently on view in the United States. The richly carved and ornately guilded wall panels were designed during the reign of Louis XVI, and the room was first dismantled at its original rue Saint-Dominique location in 1877, eventually getting donated to the California Palace of the Legion of Honor in San Francisco in 1959. In recent years, however, the curators felt that the lighting was missing the mark, and so the decision was made to restore the room to its original 18th century appearance.

This meant that no modern lighting equipment could be visible, which presented a challenge for the lighting design team at Auerbach Glasow French. Furthermore, the designers also had to create an atmosphere that was representative of the time, which meant re-creating a quality of illumination that would emulate the look of candlelight and the room’s set scene: the gray twilight of the Paris sky. An additional layer of complexity was the fact that the historic fixtures were too fragile to move and had to be rewired and retrofitted on site.

Throughout the project, the lighting designers cleverly figured out ways to conceal new lighting elements within the existing luminaires. For example, 7W faux wax candles are used in the historic fixtures to mimic the glow of candlelight, and 1W 14V automotive “glow lights” further enhance the feel. To achieve “Paris twilight,” fiber optic spotlights hidden in the chandelier are combined with LED grazing uplights in the narrow window cavities and 20W adjustable MR16 spotlights hidden in the wall sconce stanchions. To meet present-day requirements, emergency and work lights are concealed in a linear cove tucked into the historic cornice.

This intricate coordination of technical details has resulted in a restoration that not only captures the architectural spirit of this 18th century interior but the quality of illumination so distinct to the pre-electric lighting world.

Details 

Project: California Palace of the Legion of Honor, Salon Doré, San Francisco • Client: Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco, San Francisco • Architect: Andrew Skurman Architects, San Francisco • Lighting Designer: Auerbach Glasow French, San Francisco • Team Members: Patricia Glasow, Marlene Lieu • Photographer: John F. Martin Photography (except for “before” image) • Project Size: 673 square feet • Project Renovation Cost: $2 million • Lighting Cost: $317,000 • Watts per Square Foot: 1.3 (per square foot for exhibition); 0.96 per square foot for work light—not used together • Code Compliance: California Title 24 • Manufacturers: Acuity Brands/Winona Lighting, Lighting Services Inc, Lucifer Lighting, Luxam Phoenix Day, SPI

Jury Comments

• The lighting design is impressive given the limitations placed upon the design. • The technical sophistication is mind-blowing. • One has to really know lighting design in order to create this scheme.


About the Author

Elizabeth Donoff

Elizabeth Donoff is Editor-at-Large of Architectural Lighting (AL). She served as Editor-in-Chief from 2006 to 2017. She joined the editorial team in 2003 and is a leading voice in the lighting community speaking at industry events such as Lightfair and the International Association of Lighting Designers Annual Enlighten Conference, and has twice served as a judge for the Illuminating Engineering Society New York City Section’s (IESNYC) Lumen Award program. In 2009, she received the Brilliance Award from the IESNYC for dedicated service and contribution to the New York City lighting community. Over the past 11 years, under her editorial direction, Architectural Lighting has received a number of prestigious B2B journalism awards. In 2017, Architectural Lighting was a Top Ten Finalist for Magazine of the Year from the American Society of Business Publication Editors' AZBEE Awards. In 2016, Donoff received the Jesse H. Neal Award for her Editor’s Comments in the category of Best Commentary/Blog, and in 2015, AL received a Jesse H. Neal Award for Best Media Brand (Overall Editorial Excellence).Prior to her entry into design journalism, Donoff worked in New York City architectural offices including FXFowle where she was part of the project teams for the Reuters Building at Three Times Square and the New York Times Headquarters. She is a graduate of Bates College in Lewiston, Me., and she earned her Master of Architecture degree from the School of Architecture at Washington University in St. Louis.

No recommended contents to display.

Upcoming Events

  • Design Smarter: Leveraging GIS, BIM, and Open Data for Better Site Selection & Collaboration

    Live Webinar

    Register for Free
  • Slate Reimagined: The Surprising Advantages of Slate Rainscreen Cladding

    Webinar

    Register Now
  • The State of Residential Design Today: Innovations and Insights from RADA-Winning Architects

    Webinar

    Register for Free
All Events